Chicago Tribune | How to buy olive oil Chicago Tribune The three oils in this series are mild and buttery, each with a flavor profile that comes from the olives. Purchase California Olive Ranch oils from Jewel, Mariano's, Fresh Thyme and Meijer. From $9.99. (Kimberley Hasselbrink / California Olive Ranch). Producers of the Best Greek Olive Oils React to Their NYIOOC Awards |